Florida weather can be rough on fences. The scorching heat, extreme humidity, strong winds and heavy rainfall can shorten the service life of a lesser material.

Aluminum and vinyl dominate the conversation about Florida fence durability. Neither material is flawless, but there’s a good reason Floridians choose them. Learn their strengths and weaknesses to decide which is better when comparing houses to buy or increasing the value of a property you plan to sell.

Why Do Aluminum and Vinyl Make the Best Fencing for Florida Homeowners?

A close-up of a white picket fence. Image via Unsplash.

Aluminum and vinyl have distinct qualities that solidify their argument for being the best fencing material for Florida homes. However, ease of maintenance separates them from the rest.

Aluminum fences can get dirty, but they only need a quick wash to be spotless again. They’re typically powder-coated, making them less susceptible to scratches, chipping, peeling and fading. While you can repaint aluminum fences to refresh their look, you can keep the original color and finish for decades without noticing significant surface defects.

Vinyl fences require minimal upkeep. Manufacturers add color pigments directly to them during extrusion instead of spraying or coating them with paint once fabricated. Vinyl isn’t inherently immune to ultraviolet radiation, but it receives UV inhibitors during manufacturing to prevent discoloration. Painting this material is ill-advised if you want to keep the warranty intact — however, if that’s not a concern, you can give it a makeover with the correct repainting approach.

Sustainability is another reason aluminum and vinyl are desirable fencing materials. Either is an excellent choice for curbing your carbon footprint, reducing landfill waste and preserving virgin resources.

Aluminum is infinitely recyclable without losing its fundamental properties, and more fence manufacturers design their products with recycled content. Recycling this metal consumes 95% less energy than extracting it from bauxite ores, so buying fences made from recycled aluminum is an environmentally sound decision.

Vinyl is also highly recyclable. It gets a bad rap for containing ethylene, which comes from fossil fuels. However, this material also contains 57% salt, a widely abundant and renewable resource.

Aluminum Fence Benefits and Drawbacks

Image description: A dark-colored metal fence bordering a brick townhouse. Image via Unsplash.

These benefits boost aluminum’s case for being a reliable fence material. 

• Attractive appearance: Aluminum fences generally resemble wrought-iron pickets. Their traditional look blends well with conventional architectural styles.

• Corrosion resistance: Uncoated aluminum develops a protective layer when exposed to oxygen and never rusts. Though aluminum fences may deteriorate more quickly when installed near the coast, powder coating helps neutralize salty air’s corrosiveness. Bushes can be abrasive, so regularly trimming adjacent vegetation prevents damage and maintains the finish’s integrity.

• Longevity: The average aluminum fence lasts a few decades, but the lifespans of the best-cared-for ones can be twice as long.

Aluminum is an imperfect fencing material. Here are its most significant downsides.

• Lightweight: Aluminum weighs roughly one-third as much as copper or iron. Its lightweightness makes it less challenging to install but easy to bypass. Maximizing your fence’s height, designing it with spikes and pairing it with a robust locking system will enhance its security.

• Privacy: Most aluminum fence designs hardly offer concealment. Pickets can’t obscure the view of your home from the street and your neighbors.

Vinyl Fence Advantages and Disadvantages

Image description: A wood-looking fence with vegetation growing atop. Image via Unsplash.

Vinyl fences are advantageous because of these strengths.

• Wood-like aesthetics: Vinyl is a low-maintenance alternative to timber. Its appearance can mimic authentic wood grain without being prone to moisture and pest damage, earning it a reputation for beauty and durability among Florida fence materials.

• Solid construction: Vinyl fences elevate home privacy and block sounds. They can turn your backyard into a secluded oasis, safe from prying eyes and away from noise. 

• Security: A tall, sturdy vinyl fence can discourage potential intruders, convincing them to find an easier target.

Critics often cite these two reasons to argue against vinyl fencing.

• Installation cost: Vinyl fences are more complicated to set up, increasing installation time and difficulty. Spending less on maintenance makes up for their relatively high upfront cost. 

• Repairability: Fixing damaged vinyl fences involves replacing the compromised panels. You can’t patch them up. Fortunately, they’re weather-resistant enough to merit fewer repair jobs over time.

Aluminum vs. Vinyl Fence — What’s the Verdict?

Image description: A white picket fence surrounding a house on a corner lot. Image via Unsplash.

Aluminum and vinyl make compelling arguments for being the best fencing materials in Florida. It ultimately boils down to your budget and style preference. If you’re still on the fence, you can’t go wrong either way.