You might have expected that your house would sell for exactly what you set the price for, and a buyer making an offer for much less could be pretty frustrating. So what exactly makes for a lowball offer? Typically its 25 percent or less below list. But with all things being unequal, what makes an offer a lowball may vary from market to market and price range to price range.

You could know off the bat when an offer is just downright ridiculous, but it’s still best to not let your emotions get the better of you and consult with your agent because they might have a better gauge and understanding as to how offers go. It’s tempting to block off further negotiation with buyers who make such offers but remember to keep your calm because after all, you are engaging in business. It could be that your buyer may have just gotten bad advice from people around them on how they should price their offer, so it’s still advisable to keep communication lines open. The offer may have not started on the right foot, but tables can be turned if you just know how to negotiate.

Don’t waste your time thinking how you might be perceived. Consider all offers with a cool head and you might end up with a good deal. You can have your agent ask the buyer’s end on their reasons for making an offer lower than the asking price. Knowing their answer could actually be beneficial to you; you could view your property using a different lens. Are there parts in the house that needs fixing? Has the house been for sale for longer than the ideal time? Knowing the answers to questions such as those would help you evaluate just what you need to improve on it so that it could look more appealing to the market.

A trusty and experienced agent could spot when a buyer – despite making a low offer – is smitten with the house and are willing to raise their offer.

If you’re going to make a counter offer, it’s best to present it with data such as a market’s list-to-sales price ratio. Also, you can have your agent make a written document containing the best comparable homes to yours. Include the following statistics from two months ago to the same measurements today:

a.) Number of similar homes on the market.

b.) Number of similar homes sold and closed since the listing’s inception.

c.) Number of listings that expired unsold.

d.) Number of pending transactions.

e.) Number of new similar listings (your competition) with the data sheets and pricing

By knowing all these information, you would have an wise estimate on the lowest and highest price you can expect.

Keep Reading

More South Florida Real Estate Guides

Fort Lauderdale Home Buying Guide 2026

Step-by-step guide to buying a home in Fort Lauderdale — neighborhoods, financing, and closing costs.

First-Time Homebuyer Checklist 2026

Everything first-time buyers need to know before making an offer in South Florida.

Best Neighborhoods in South Florida 2026

Compare the top South Florida communities by lifestyle, schools, walkability, and home prices.

Fort Lauderdale Real Estate Market 2026

Current market trends, price data, and outlook for buyers and sellers in Fort Lauderdale.

Florida Real Estate Investment Guide 2026

How to evaluate, buy, and profit from investment properties in South Florida.

Real Estate Agent Commissions Explained (2026 NAR Rules)

What buyers and sellers pay under the new NAR settlement rules in Florida.

Living in Weston FL — Homes, Schools & Lifestyle Guide 2026

A deep dive into Weston's master-planned communities, A-rated schools, and home values.

Victoria Park Fort Lauderdale Guide

Explore homes, walkability, and the charming character of Victoria Park in Fort Lauderdale.

3 Biggest Real Estate Investor Mistakes in Florida

Costly errors Florida investors make — and how to avoid them when buying rental property.

Scott Lehr, PA — Licensed South Florida Real Estate Agent

Scott Lehr, PA

Licensed Florida Real Estate Agent · 20+ Years Experience

Scott Lehr is a top-producing South Florida Realtor® specializing in Fort Lauderdale, Weston, Boca Raton, and Broward County. He has helped hundreds of buyers and sellers navigate the South Florida market, from first-time home purchases to luxury waterfront estates.

View Scott's full bio →  ·  Call (954) 342-6180

Browse South Florida Homes for Sale

Neighborhood & Community Guides

Buyer Guides by City

Seller Guides by City

View all South Florida MLS listings  ·  Map Search  ·  📊 South Florida Market Report